![]() |
I just heard Trent Dilfer say, “tight ends are a young quarterback’s best friend”. You hear this all the time, but it seems like a load of bullshit to me. I decided to do my own non-scientific study in order to test this theory. First, let's look at the top 5 tight ends in terms of receptions before week 11:
TE Age of QB
1. Jason Witten 32
2. Tony Gonzalez 27
3. Rob Gronkowski 35
4. Jimmy Graham 33
5. Brandon Meyers 32
Of the top 5 tight ends, none of their quarterbacks are young. In fact, all of them are relatively old, besides Matt Ryan, and I don’t think the MVP candidate would appreciate the implication that he still needs Tony Gonzalez as a “safety blanket”. This data seems to imply that tight ends are used more by teams with (bold opinions alert!) good tight ends.
You also might notice that these teams are ones that throw the ball a lot. A skeptic might note that young QBs might not throw the ball as much as veterans, but they might exhibit a greater propensity to complete passes to tight ends. Since I am extremely bored, I decided to calculate the Tight end Usage Rate (( TE receptions/ Total completions) x100) of the five youngest starting QBs and the five oldest starting QBs in the NFL.
QB Age TUR
1.Robert Griffin III 22 24%
2. Andrew Luck 23 22%
3. Russell Wilson 23 21%
4. Cam Newton 23 26%
5. Blaine Gabbert 23 18%
QB Age TUR
1.Peyton Manning 36 24%
2. Tom Brady 35 29%
3. Drew Brees 33 22%
4.Tony Romo 32 31%
5.Carson Palmer 32 23%
On average, the older quarterbacks have a higher TUR than the younger quarterbacks, which we could attribute to an ability to move through reads quickly, exploit mismatches, or get the ball out quickly(therefore needing less blockers), but I think that their offensive schemes seem to be the deciding factor. Whether your QB was born in the 70’s, the 80’s, or the 90’s, his “friendliness’ with his tight end is more correlated with the whims of his offensive coordinator than the date of his birth. Some offensive schemes use tight ends primarily as blockers, while others seek to use the tight end to create mismatches. This seems like a pretty obvious fact, but it is one that sage analysts, like Trent Dilfer, routinely ignore. Sometimes, I wonder whether these "experts" are experts of football or of the cliches of football.

0 comments:
Post a Comment